2024 has been a nasty year in terms of the national conversation. Most of us are glad the election is past, but we know the bickering is not. What might sooth our partisan pain? Perhaps a generous dose of thanks. The cultural left doesn’t like Thanksgiving because of the suspected colonialism and oppression infecting the story of the Plymouth Pilgrims. The theological right doesn’t like civil religion, and hence Thanksgiving, because it is theistic at best and its celebration rightly lacks credal integrity. Possibly fair criticisms on all accounts. But getting rid of Thanksgiving with its historical roots and questionable theology means we don’t listen to wise words from the past, and we have lost much. The cure will not take. Give thanks!
Abraham Lincoln’s 1863 Thanksgiving Proclamation: Continue reading